This turn of events was even more alarming than Sam had been expecting - he quickly decided he'd have preferred anger.
"What? No!" he cried, reaching around his beer bottle and grabbing Gene's hands, pulling them from his face and squeezing them in his own. "You're not pathetic," he insisted, looking intently into the mortal's lovely face. "You should stay mad! You were kept in the dark and so much was hidden from you that you didn't have any idea how duped you were. It doesn't make you pathetic, just uninformed. And I feel bad that I made you feel this way," he finished worriedly, frowning as he let go of Gene's hand and reached up to cup his face briefly. After a moment, he let go and sat back.
"Look, this all feels really heavy, suddenly," he said, drawing a short circle in the air between them with his downward-angled first two fingers. "You want to go for a walk or something? Clear our heads?" He wasn't sure what it would achieve, but he felt like moving at that moment, hoping it might make processing things easier. Despite no-one really paying attention to them, he felt like he was dropping some really heavy stuff on Gene and fresh air would both allow them to talk more freely and hopefully make the topic of conversation feel a little lighter. If that was at all possible.